Constitutional Court of Guatemala ordered immediate suspension of “Fenix” nickel mine operation in Mayan Q’eqchi’ territories

Will decision impact the Hudbay Minerals (Skye Resources) lawsuits in Canada, as decision puts into question the underlying legality of Hudbay/Skye’s years of mining in Guatemala (2005-2011), during which time the repression and harms linked to their mining operation occurred, including killings, gang-rapes, shootings, forced evictions and community destruction?

“Fenix” mountain-top removal nickel mine, Mayan Q’eqchi’ territories, eastern Guatemala

“Fenix” mountain-top removal nickel mine, Mayan Q’eqchi’ territories, eastern Guatemala

The mine is operated by the Guatemalan Nickel Company (CGN), owned since 2011 by the Swiss-based Solway Investment Group. Prior to that, the owner was Hudbay Minerals and Skye Resources, 2005-2011.

Ratifying its own June 19, 2020 ruling, Guatemala’s Constitutional Court concluded that CGN has been illegally operating the mine since 2005, that a legally required consultation process was never carried out with the impacted Q’eqchi’ peoples, and that a proper Environmental Impact Assessment was never carried out.


The Court ordered:

  • The Ministry of Energy and Mines to limit the territorial space of the license to 6.29 Km-sq of the 247.9978 Km-sq originally authorized, as the Environmental Impact Assessment only covered this smaller portion;

  • Pre-consultation and consultation processes provided for in ILO Convention 169, with the peoples settled in the area of impact of Fenix mining project;

  • The complete suspension of all mining within the 6.29 Km-sq area, until the consultation process is concluded.

The Attorney General’s office and the Ministry of Energy and Mines are now obliged to enforce the suspension of the mine.


More information

Background
MEM suspende licencia de explotación de Fénix, la última mina metálica activa en Guatemala
Por Rosa María Bolaños, 23 febrero 2021
https://www.prensalibre.com/economia/mem-suspende-licencia-de-explotacion-de-fenix-la-ultima-mina-metalica-activa-en-guatemala/

Hudbay Minerals head of security pleads guilty to killing and assaults near Guatemala mine
Rights Action, January 8, 2021
https://mailchi.mp/rightsaction/hudbay-minerals-head-of-security-pleads-guilty-to-killing-and-assaults-near-guatemala-mine

Archives - Hudbay Minerals (INCO, Skye Resources, Solway Investment Group)
https://rightsaction.org/hudbay-minerals-archives